Sow Planner

When to plant carrots in Zone 5

For a middle-of-the-road Zone 5 location, plan around a last spring frost of May 17 (10% chance of a later frost; the typical, 50% date is May 3). On that basis carrots go outdoors Apr 19 – May 3.

Key dates for Zone 5

Cautious (recommended)TypicalEarliest date, early vs. late part of zone
Plant outdoors (spring)Apr 19 – May 3Apr 5 – Apr 19Apr 13 to Apr 29

Cautious = median, across Zone 5 ZIP codes, of each ZIP’s 10%-risk last frost (May 17) and first fall frost (Sep 24). Typical = the 50% dates (May 3, Oct 7). The last column shows the earliest cautious date for a ZIP with an early (25th percentile) vs. a late (75th percentile) frost season in this zone.

Chart: when to plant carrots in USDA hardiness zone 5

Why your zone isn’t enough

Hardiness zones are based on the coldest winter night, not on frost dates. Across the 4,792 Zone 5 ZIP codes with a NOAA frost record, the typical last spring frost ranges from Apr 23 to May 20 (10th–90th percentile). That’s a 4-week spread, so a planting date for “Zone 5” can be weeks off for your garden. Your ZIP code gives dates from your nearest station.

The timing rule

Cold toleranceSemi-hardy (tolerates light frost) — Purdue Extension HO-186: Indiana Vegetable Planting Calendar (R. Lerner)
How it’s plantedDirect-seeded in the garden — Purdue Extension HO-186: Indiana Vegetable Planting Calendar (R. Lerner)
Plant outdoors (spring)2–4 weeks before last spring frost (source wording: “plant 2-4 weeks before last spring frost”)
Soil temperature for germinationoptimum 80°F (range 45-85°F); minimum 40°F, maximum 95°F — Purdue Extension HO-186: Indiana Vegetable Planting Calendar (R. Lerner)

Also due that week in Zone 5

Beets (plant outdoors Apr 19), Cauliflower (plant outdoors Apr 19), Celery (plant outdoors Apr 19), Swiss chard (plant outdoors Apr 19), Chinese cabbage (plant outdoors Apr 19), Lettuce (plant outdoors Apr 19), Parsnips (plant outdoors Apr 19), Parsley (plant outdoors Apr 26).

Zone 5 cities

City (ZIP, zone)Cautious last frostPlant outdoors
Minneapolis, MN (55401, 5a)May 7Apr 9 – Apr 23
Sioux Falls, SD (57104, 5a)May 14Apr 16 – Apr 30
Billings, MT (59101, 5a)May 24Apr 26 – May 10
Cheyenne, WY (82001, 5b)May 26Apr 28 – May 12
Burlington, VT (05401, 5b)May 11Apr 13 – Apr 27
Des Moines, IA (50309, 5b)May 2Apr 4 – Apr 18
Anchorage, AK (99501, 5a)May 9Apr 11 – Apr 25
Green Bay, WI (54301, 5b)May 16Apr 18 – May 2
Duluth, MN (55802, 5a)May 25Apr 27 – May 11

Downtown ZIP code, nearest NOAA station, cautious (10%-risk) dates.

Other zones: Zone 3 · Zone 4 · Zone 6 · Zone 7 · Zone 8 · Zone 9 · Zone 10 · all carrots timing · Zone 5 calendar

Sources